«

»

Aug 13 2016

Battle of the Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks | Caolion, Estee Edit, Nudestick

 

Even in my 30’s, oily skin, which accentuates my not so small pores, continues to plague me. Add to that the Summer heat and humidity and things can become a hot mess real fast. I’m always up for trying something that will help control the situation. Enter some conveniently packaged (and hopefully effective) pore blurring and mattifying sticks. Pore and oil control in stick form? Thought that was so neat! I’m excited to bring you guys another battle as I compare how each of them performed. My biggest area of concern in terms of enlarged pores in this area at the top of my cheeks just below my eyes. Oh, and let me apologize ahead of time for the close-up shots of my face but hey, what better way to show if the product actually works?

 
Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 

Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 
Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 

First up in this battle, we have the Caolion Pore Sebum Control Moisture Stick  which is described as a “sebum-controlling moisture balm that helps maintain makeup like it was freshly applied.” It promises to cover pores, smooth uneven skin, moisturize, and soothe while promoting natural radiance through hydration. It is designed to be used before or after makeup application.

This pore blurring and mattifying stick is packaged in a pink and white twistable tube. Although the product itself also appears to have a pink tint, it actually applies clear. It has a smooth, non-sticky balm like texture. Once applied to the skin, it imparts a refreshing, cooling sensation that feels quite nice. And it absorbs very quickly. When I touch my face I cannot detect anything which is nice. Also, there is no fragrance but the faintest hint of scent that can probably be attributed to one of the ingredients.

 
Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 

The oil absorbing agent in the Caolion stick is silica while I’m guessing that the pore blurring ingredient is a silicone (listed as Bis-PEG-18 Methyl Ether Dimethyl Silane). Despite the inclusion of silicones, the product doesn’t have an overly “silicone-y” feeling to it which is pleasant. I’m not always the biggest fan of silicone heavy primers. In other words, there’s not too much slip. Regarding it’s ability to control oil, I’d say it does a fairly good job. When I use the stick I do notice a moderate improvement in overall oily-ness. On the other hand, I was less than impressed with the product’s pore blurring capabilities. Granted my pores are on the larger size (and look even bigger this close-up) but I expected more.

 
Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks Review
 

Ingredients: Water, Butylene Glycol, Glycerin, Bis-PEG-18 Methyl Ether Dimethyl Silane, Sodium Stearate, Xylitol, Zanthoxylum Piperitum Fruit Extract, Pulsatilla Koreana Extract, Usnea Barbata (Lichen) Extract, Silica Dimethyl Silylate, Brachychiton Acerifolius Flower Extract, Coceth-7, PPG-1-PEG-9 Lauryl Glycol Ether, Potassium Alginate, CI 16185.

The Caolion Pore Sebum Control Moisture Stick contains 0.2 oz of product and retails $16.00 USD.

The Estee Edit Pore Vanishing Stick is an “easy, glide-on stick to blur the look of pores and minimize shine and oil.” It is designed to be used alone or as a primer under makeup. Estee Lauder promises that with a single swipe, pores appear blurred, skintone looks more even, and shine and oil are reduced.

I received this trial size with a Sephora purchase. Like the Caolion stick, the Estee Edit version comes packaged in a twist-up tube. As you can see, the product itself is two-toned. Estee Lauder says that this dual-action formula has an outer core of oil-absorbing powders and an inner core with a sheer pigment that fits all skintones. I can’t really tell if the pigment actually has any color to it because when I swatch it against my skin it is completely translucent.

 
Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 

First of all, this Estee stick definitely does a nice job of leaving the skin feeling silky smooth. Like the previous stick, it also contains silica. But the main pore blurring/primer ingredient is dimethicone (a silicone) and you can definitely feel it. While it does not absorb into the skin the same way as the Caolion stick does, it does work a little better at blurring the appearance of pores. In terms of controlling oils, it did an O.K. job, probably giving me an extra hour or two before I’d usually have to blot. Also worth noting that despite swatching translucent, I do feel that the Estee Edit Pore Vanishing stick adding just the hint of color to my skin.

 
Review of Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks
 

Ingredients: Dimethicone, C12-15 Alkyl Benzoate, Polymethylsilsesquioxane, Aluminum Starch Octenylsuccinate, Polyethylene, Dimethicone Crosspolymer, Silica, Dicalcium Phosphate, [+/- Titanium Dioxide, Iron Oxides]

The full size Estee Edit Pore Vanishing Stick contains 0.24 oz and retails for $28.00 USD.

The Nudestix Matte + Blemish Pencil is “an amazonian clay pencil balm that instantly absorbs facial sebum/oils to mattify oily zones, detoxify and improve clarity without drying-out skin.” This product is a little different than the other two in both packaging and formulation. As you can see, it is a pencil format and comes with a sharpener, all housed in a mirrored tin container.

Formulation wise, it is not a pore blurring and mattifying stick as such. That is, it does not promise to do anything with pores. It does, however, promise to keep oils and spots at bay. It contains the active ingredient salicylic acid which is supposed to help with inflammation, prevent blemishes and breakouts. Additionally, unlike the previous two sticks, this one is designed to be used on bare skin. While nudestick doesn’t say whether it can be used under makeup, it does specifies that it should not be used over makeup.

 
Battle of the Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks (3)
 

There aren’t that many reviews of the Nudestix Matte + Blemish Pencil out there. However, I do recall reading one where the reviewer complained of not being able to wear makeup over this product without piling. I can see how that may happen with the primary ingredient being paraffin which gives the pencil it’s waxy feel. Luckily, I did not have that problem. My foundation worked fine over this (but I did it use it over large areas). The pencil also contains a silicone (Cyclopentasiloxane).

My favorite way to use the Nudestix is on small areas of the face where I may be experiencing breakouts. I think it does a great job of sealing in blemishes, so to speak, while also treating them. The concept is similar to using a concealer that contains an acne fighting ingredients. In my experience, however, those kind of products tend to give me a very cakey look. I much prefer to apply this treatment product because it goes on clear and then add my regular foundation and concealer on top.

 
Pore Blurring and Mattifying Sticks Review
 

Ingredients: Paraffin, Isododecane, Polubutene, Cyclopentasiloxane, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Cyclohexasiloxane, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Cyclohexasiloxane, Simmondsai Chinesis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Ozokerite, Ceresin, Hydroxystearic Acid, Silk (Serica) Powder, Stearic Acid, Tocopherol, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Palmitic Acid, Ascorbyl Palmitate, Chamomilla Recutita (Matricaria) Flower Extract.

Nudestix products are preservative free and cruelty free. The Nudestix Matte + Blemish Pencil contains 0.10 oz of product and can be found at Beautylish and Cult Beauty.

 

Conclusions: Personally I tend to prefer primers that have a creamier based like the Hourglass Mineral Veil Primer and Diorskin Forever and Ever Base (reviewed here). That being said, I cannot deny the convenience of these pore blurring and mattifying sticks. They are quick, easy to use and extremely portable. My favorite of the three is probably the Nudestix just because I like it for blemishes. The Estee Edit Pore Vanishing Stick isn’t bad and, lastly, the Caolin Pore Sebum Moisture Stick was my least favorite. It just didn’t do that great of a job with pores, in my opinion.

 

 

Is your skin oily or dry? Do these pore blurring and mattifying sticks interest you? What’s your favorite way to keep oils away and conceal pores?

 

 

 

 

The product(s) mentioned were purchased with the author’s own money. The thoughts and opinions expressed are the author’s alone. Post may contain affiliate links. For more information see Disclaimer here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Beauty Isles Signature

9 comments

Skip to comment form

  1. chocandlipstick

    The nudestix might actually be good for the brow, but I wouldn’t use it on my skin personally :/
    Angie
    http://www.chocolateandlipstick.com

  2. shireenplatt

    I have dry, dehydrated skin and thankfully my pores are nit a huge problem, yet. This is a great comparison post, Kimmy.

    Shireen | Reflection of Sanity

  3. Beautylymin

    Brilliant post! From the pics, the Estee one looks the best but the Nudestix seems to suit you better. I have dry skin so wouldn’t use any of these but I do keep my eye out for products that will blue my pores xx

    Beautylymin| Abercrombie & Fitch First Instinct Giveaway

  4. stashy

    I like the idea of a base that also helps with blemishes like the Nudestix. I would use that on my chin which is where I get hormonal spots. My skin is combo and it’s especially apparent in the summer months – so I essentially have to treat my t-zone and cheeks differently. I don’t like the super silicone-y primers just because I find they react with my foundations. I don’t battle with large pores so I mainly like primers to help my foundations last longer – right now I’m really enjoying the mineral primer from Laura Mercier.

  5. Laura Alagöz

    I have oily skin and hiding pores is what I’m all about when doing skincare. I like how travel friendly these seem and so easy to use x

    Laura
    Pink Frenzy

  6. Sakura Vietnam

    I haven’t used it yet but it seems easy to use and its ingredients is environmentally friendly.
    I guess I will give it a try. Nice review.

  7. lindalibraloca

    These sticks do interest me, but not to a point where I have ever bought one. My main concern is shine and oiliness, not pore size.

    Linda, Libra, Loca: Beauty, Baby and Backpacking

  8. Serene Kurd

    I love the sound of the Nudestix! I would definitely give it a go! it really did work on the blemishes and it’s a quick makeup tool to use! I love the idea of it 🙂

    Serene | I Am Serene L

  9. thesaltlifewife

    Ive never even thought about using one of these! Very interesting though and I love that you added the pics. Really helped to see just how well they worked!

Share your thoughts with us! Life has gotten busier for me after welcoming my little one and I may not be able to respond to every comment but will try my best. Please know that I truly appreciate every single comment. Thank you!